Can Variable Life Insurance Lose Money?
If you are asking, “can variable life insurance lose money,” the answer is yes: the policy’s cash value can fall when its investment options lose value, and fees, withdrawals, loans, or a lapse can make the outcome worse. The effect on the death benefit depends on the policy’s contract and the choices you make.
Variable life insurance combines life insurance with investment options selected by the policy owner. Unlike a fixed cash-value design, its account value is not insulated from market performance. The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s Investor.gov consumer guidance explains that the account varies with premiums, policy fees and expenses, and the performance of the selected investment options. It also says a policyholder can lose money, including some or all of the initial investment.
- Investment performance can reduce the policy’s cash value.
- Fees and expenses reduce the amount that remains in the account.
- A falling cash value does not automatically mean the face amount has fallen. The contract’s death-benefit option controls that result.
- Loans, withdrawals, and insufficient value to pay policy charges can increase lapse risk.
If you are deciding whether this product belongs in your financial plan, you can start by seeing an estimated rate in minutes. An estimate is not a guarantee and does not replace reading the policy prospectus or getting advice about your own tax situation.
See your estimated rate in minutes.
Prefer to talk it through? You can speak with a licensed life insurance agent.
- Estimates before any agent call
- No contact info needed
- Online estimates not available in New York
How does variable life insurance lose value?
It loses value when the account’s investment options fall, when policy charges exceed what the account earns, or when money is removed from the policy. The investment options may include stock or bond funds, so each option has its own risks and expenses. In most policies, these choices are what variable life subaccounts actually are, fund portfolios whose returns move the cash value.
The NAIC’s Life Insurance Buyer’s Guide says the investments selected for a variable life policy directly affect cash value. It describes variable life as having the greatest risk of losing cash value among the policy types it compares. That risk applies to the account value, not necessarily to every dollar paid in premiums, because premiums also cover insurance costs and other charges.
Fees matter even in a flat market. Investor.gov lists sales charges, surrender charges, mortality and expense risk fees, cost-of-insurance charges, administrative fees, loan interest, and underlying-fund expenses as possible costs. The exact list and amount are contract-specific. Ask for the prospectus and the policy illustration, then look at which charges are deducted from premiums or the account. Fees charged against the account can come from your premium, the cash value, or the underlying funds, so the premium alone does not show the total cost.
Can a market decline reduce the death benefit?
A market decline can affect the death benefit in some contracts, but there is no single rule for every variable life policy. Investor.gov explains that a policy may define the death benefit as the face amount, the face amount plus cash value, or the face amount plus premiums paid. Under a face-amount option, a decline in cash value does not by itself change the stated face amount. Under another option, the account value may be part of the benefit.
Loans and withdrawals are different. A policy loan can reduce cash value, reduce the death benefit, and make a lapse more likely. A no-lapse feature may keep the policy in force under stated conditions, but Investor.gov notes that electing one can significantly reduce the death benefit. Read the policy’s benefit option, loan provisions, withdrawal rules, and any lapse protection together.
Do not assume that a phrase such as “guaranteed death benefit” means the policy can never terminate. Guarantees depend on the contract, the insurer’s ability to pay, and conditions such as required premiums. A policy can lapse if its value is not enough to cover current charges and the owner does not provide the required premium or other support.
What happens if the policy lapses?
A lapse means the policy terminates because the available value or premium is not enough to pay the policy’s charges. If that happens, the beneficiary may no longer have the promised death benefit. Poor investment performance, high charges, a withdrawal, or a loan can all reduce the cushion available to pay those charges.
Review the policy statement for current cash value, surrender value, outstanding loans, charges, and the premium needed to keep coverage in force. Ask the insurer for an in-force illustration if you are considering a premium change, withdrawal, or loan. An illustration can show how different assumptions affect future values, but it is not a promise of investment performance.
How is variable life different from whole life?
The central difference is how cash value is determined. The NAIC buyer’s guide compares variable and non-variable life by the way their investment choices affect cash value. In variable life, selected investment options directly affect the account value. In whole life, the policy generally follows a set premium schedule and provides guaranteed elements stated in the contract. The policy documents, not the product label alone, determine the actual guarantees and non-guaranteed values.
Variable life may appeal to someone who understands investment risk and wants control over the available options inside a permanent life policy. It may be a poor fit for someone who cannot tolerate account-value declines, needs a short-term savings vehicle, or would struggle to keep paying charges during a prolonged downturn. Those are suitability questions, not predictions about returns.
For a broader overview of the easiest life insurance buying process, review the policy types, coverage need, premium commitment, and application requirements before focusing on projected account values. A licensed life insurance agent can explain policy mechanics, but you should also review the prospectus and consider whether you need independent tax or investment advice.
Are losses deductible for federal income tax?
A decrease in a variable life policy’s account value is not automatically a deductible loss. Tax treatment depends on what happened to the contract, the amount received, the policy’s cost basis, loans, and other facts. The IRS Interactive Tax Assistant asks whether a surrendered policy paid more than its cost, which shows why a surrender cannot be evaluated from the market value alone.
If you surrender a policy for cash, compare the amount received with your investment in the contract and keep the insurer’s tax reporting. If the policy terminates with an outstanding loan, the loan may be treated as a distribution for federal tax purposes. The IRS says the answer depends on the details supplied by the taxpayer, so ask a tax professional before surrendering, exchanging, borrowing from, or withdrawing from the policy. This article is general information, not tax advice.
What should you check before buying or changing one?
Start with the policy prospectus and the illustration. Confirm which investment options are available, how often values are reported, and which expenses reduce the account. Ask what happens if a chosen fund loses value, if you stop or reduce premiums, or if you take a loan or withdrawal.
- Coverage: Identify the face amount, death-benefit option, and conditions that can change the benefit.
- Costs: List sales charges, insurance charges, administration fees, fund expenses, surrender charges, and loan interest.
- Funding: Ask what premium is required to keep the policy in force under adverse investment results.
- Alternatives: Compare the policy’s purpose with other life insurance designs and with your need for accessible savings.
- Review: Revisit the policy after major financial changes and request an updated in-force illustration.
These questions help separate an investment-performance risk from a coverage need. They also show whether the policy remains affordable if the account value falls.
What is the practical answer?
Yes, variable life insurance can lose money. The cash value can decline because of investment losses and can be reduced further by fees, surrender charges, loans, or withdrawals. A death-benefit decline is contract-specific, while a lapse can end coverage altogether. Read the prospectus, illustration, and current statement before making a change.
If you want a low-pressure starting point, you can see an estimated rate in minutes and then discuss what information a licensed life insurance agent would need to assess possible coverage. Treat that estimate as an initial planning step, not a promise of approval, performance, or tax treatment.
Insurance Researcher & Writer
Hannah McCullough is the Director of Operations for Insurance By Heroes, overseeing policy handling, compliance, and customer service. A former teacher and coach, she served more than six years in public education and holds a Master of Education in Educational Leadership from East Central University.